Sunday, November 24, 2013

Response to Course Material

Where does one start when we had such a busy month! I guess I will start with my very first fish bowl experience. I was at first intrigued by the idea of a conversation held just by a few, but once I experienced it I realized it is very similar to Socratic discussions; the only difference was that I caught my self zoning out while conversations were going on. The next exercise that stuck with me was the mood and atmosphere paragraph. Each time we wrote a paragraph about the pictures given I felt like an author. I am sure a few books were inspired by pictures because it is easy to create a story to fit with the image, like the picture of the angry men, we kept trying to write about what they were looking at and the event lead up to their anxious faces. I truly hope we continue to do more of these exercises which are not only fun but also help me focus on using strong verbs. I think that ending with Shakespeare's  Hamlet is fitting because it follows our classes schedule. I am so excited to hear other people's opinions on this play because tragedies are not experienced the same way they were during Shakespeare's time. But the last scene did remind me of "Game of Thrones" because there is an episode where the Starks go to a wedding and the whole crew is killed by the insane fief lord. When I relate Hamlet to this episode it is easier to view the play as tragic and not comedic, but still the way people just dropped in this play was a bit comedic.  

3 comments:

  1. Ana,

    Great response!I honestly love the way you tied different elements in to your response and related the stuff we are learning to current events. As far as the fishbowl experience, I had a much different one than you! While you said sitting on the outer edge puts you to sleep I felt like I constantly wanted t jump in and talk! Even though I wasn't a huge fan of Death of a Salesman, I loved discussing it and figuring out the symbols in the text and the movie. With the mood and atmosphere exercises I just so happened to agree with you! I think they are very intriguing and fun, but I'm sure unlike you, I am not so good and thinking and writing down all the ideas the class gets from those and I can't seem to get the hang of it, although hopefully we keep doing them so I get better. Finally, as for right now, discussing and just finishing up reading Hamlet, this is my favorite part of all three of the plays we have read. It seems like all is going well in your interpretation of the class so I hope it continues! Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ana,
    I am very much so a Game of Thrones fan, I don't know how you can't be if you see the first five minutes of any episode. The red wedding came to my mind as well when we read the last scene as a class, the are both so horrible and filled with death. I started balling in Game of Thrones, I didn't in Hamlet so I'm not sure why the tragedy didn't hit me as hard. I think that your post would be easier to understand if it was broken up into the different activities we did in class and maybe elaborated a bit on each one. I am also so excited to see what we find out about Hamlet in our discussions as a class after the close reading. I feel like there is still a lot we haven't touched on. You did a very nice job on the post, hitting almost everything we did in class. Keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete
  3. GAME OF THRONES! I completely agree with your thought, and especially in watching and discussing the movies, Game of Thrones has often come to my mind during our time with Hamlet. In other words, this is a great connection. I would suggest for next time that you elaborate a bit more on some of the topics by trying to add in similar connections. In the voice lessons, do you feel like that you have already learned the material in past classes? Has reading Hamlet this year differed from other experiences with Shakespeare? Did you find the fish bowls to be boring or was it just the lack of direct engagement in the conversation? I am also eager to continue our in-class discussion of Hamlet, and in a text that complex, I am eager to see what interesting things we will uncover. Great post!

    ReplyDelete